Consequences of Non-Maintenance of Books of Account

Consequences of non-maintenance of books of account

Proper bookkeeping is required in business and finance, as several Indian laws require. Maintaining books of account accurately and regularly illustrates a business’s financial health and helps it follow all tax and regulatory guidelines. However, many Indian small businesses and startups ignore this key issue, facing various legal, financial, and operational challenges. It examines the consequences of non-maintenance of books of accounts under Indian law and taxation, explaining the laws, penalties, and widespread concerns businesses may encounter.

1. Legal Requirement to Maintain Books of Account

Under the Income Tax Act, 1961
According to Section 44AA of the Income Tax Act, the law requires certain professionals and businesses to keep accounts. When the gross income of a professional (such as in the legal, medical, engineering, or accounting fields) is over ₹2.5 lakh in any of the three prior years, they are required to keep certain records.

If a business earns more than ₹2.5 lakh or turns over more than ₹25 lakh in any of the three years before the assessment, the tax authority requires detailed income and expense records from the business. If these records are not kept, businesses may experience penalties under Section 271A.

Under the Companies Act, 2013:

According to Section 128 of the Companies Act, all companies are required to keep their account books at their registered office. The content in these books must reflect a true and fair account of the company’s position and should be held for at least 8 years.

The books are allowed to be kept electronically, as long as they follow the proper guidelines. Directors need to make sure that routine records are managed and safeguarded.

Under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) Act

GST-registered businesses need to record their supplies, stock, input tax credit, tax they have paid, and other necessary data. Should this not happen, organisations could face scrutiny, evaluatio,n and penalties.

2. Penalties for Non-Compliance

Penalty under the Income Tax Act:

Section 271A: If a person or organisation does not obey Section 44AA, they may have to pay a penalty of ₹25,000.

Section 271B: If accounts are not audited (when they should be done), the company may be imposed a penalty of 0.5% of its turnover, with the maximum amount being ₹1.5 lakh.

Penalty under the Companies Act:

A company and its officers, such as directors, can be fined between ₹50,000 and ₹5 lakhs if books are not maintained properly.

If a company is found to have been fraudulently or wrongly managed, the directors may suffer disqualification and possible imprisonment as a result.

Penalty under the GST Act:

If books are not maintained, as required by Sections 35 and 36 of the CGST Act, it can lead to general penalties which may reach ₹25,000.

Mistakes in recording can also cause the company to lose input tax credit or have credits they have claimed reversed.

3. Increased Risk of Tax Scrutiny and Assessment

If you do not have the right books, you could encounter problems in the assessment of income tax or GST. Whenever there is not enough reliable documentation:

• The AO may choose to assess the taxes based on its best judgment under Section 144 of the Act.
• As a result, the tax demand can be higher and lead to penalties.
• If there is a problem with the declaration, the taxpayer cannot explain or justify themselves using real records.

As a result, such cases often require a lot of time and effort before being resolved.

4. Denial of Tax Benefits and Deductions

Many exemptions and deductions permitted by the Income Tax Act can only be claimed if you have the proper documentation. Without proper books:

• Businesses might lose the benefits of certain deductions available in sections like 80C, 80G, or 35AD.
• Sometimes, claiming certain expenses for business is not allowed by professionals.
• Making a capital gains calculation is difficult when there is no information on the cost or sale.

5. Impact on Loans and Creditworthiness

Banks, NBFCs, and investors use a company’s books of account to judge how healthy it is financially. If a company neglects good record-keeping:

• Getting loans, term credits, or overdraft facilities may be difficult for it.
• This may cause your business to be seen as riskier for lenders, making it more difficult to get money in times of need.
• Trust in the business’s management and how things are run may start to fade for investors.

6. Operational and Strategic Setbacks

Not maintaining accounts can influence and complicate decisions made within a company. Businesses may face:

• Not understanding how much money is coming in or going out can lead to cash flow issues.
• Issues with managing stock and running the supply chain.
• Struggles to make accurate plans and estimates for the future.
• The inability to spot financial fraud or leakage as soon as it happens.

At the end of the day, unkept financial records hurt the overall functioning of a company.

7. Disqualification and Prosecution of Directors

Companies that do not properly maintain their books may leave directors and responsible officers at risk of legal action. The RoC can take the first steps to conduct an inspection or investigation. Directors may face:

• A provision for disqualification under Section 164 of the Companies Act.
• Fraud cases may be prosecuted using Section 447 of the Penal Code.
• Penalties may be for civil or criminal matters according to how much the requirements are ignored.

8. Issues During Tax Audits and Due Diligence

Businesses must complete due diligence whenever they are involved in mergers, acquisitions or raising capital. When no proper records are present:

• The business valuation may suffer.
• Both auditors and investors can discover ambiguous behaviour.
• Sometimes, the deal is put on hold or dropped completely.

Get Started with TaxDunia 

Maintaining accounts is important not only to follow the law, but also for running a business. Laws in India require that financial records be always prepared and stored carefully. They make sure companies are held accountable, assist in paying taxes, and allow businesses to make the best choices.

Hence, every business, big or small, should prioritise good accounting and look for the best team or outside help. The expenses needed for compliance are less than the expenses required for not complying.