Speculative Income: Definition & Taxation

Income from speculation and its taxation are governed under specific provisions in the Income Tax Act, 1961, in India. Understanding this subtlety is important for a person or entity involved in high-risk financial activity. As its name suggests, speculative income is the whole or part of a taxpayer’s income which is not realised until it is earned, as it is based on future events. Income from sources like intraday equity trading and unregistered/unregulated derivative trading is an example of speculative income. This article highlights speculative income, its definition & taxation in detail.

Definition of Speculative Income in India

According to the income tax law section 43 (5) of 1961, speculation means that a “speculative transaction” has taken place when a contract for the purchase or sale of any commodity, including stocks and shares, is to be settled otherwise than by actual delivery or transfer. For the most part, it simply means transactions wherein there is no intention on the part of a party to take or give physical delivery of the asset; the income arises from just making a price difference over a short duration.

Common Examples in India:

• Intraday Equity Trading: Buying shares and selling them on the same trading day without allowing the shares to enter or leave your Demat account.
• Unregistered/Unregulated Derivative Trading: Any transaction that has taken place without proper registration using derivative instruments.

Available Exemptions and Clarifications

The Indian tax regime provides particular exemptions concerning some trading activities that keep the transaction from being qualified as speculative and alter tax treatment from non-speculative activity.

1. Non-Speculative Derivative Transactions (F&O): Section 43(5)(d): One of the most notable exceptions is made for derivative transactions (futures and options- F&O) transacted on recognized stock exchanges such as NSE or BSE. These transactions aren’t regarded as speculative if their settlement occurs without actual delivery and they qualify under the terms of transactions screened through a registered stockbroker.
2. Tax Implications for F&O (Non-Speculative Business Income):
   • Loss Set-Off: Set off of any F&O loss in the same financial year is permissible against any other business income, both speculative and non-speculative, as well as against other heads of income such as house property or capital gains, but not against salary income.
   • Loss Carry Forward: Unabsorbed F&O losses can be carried forward for the next eight assessment years. These losses carried forward can be absorbed against any business income in the years that follow.
   • Presumptive Taxation (Section 44AD): Eligible individuals, HUFs, partnership firms (excluding LLPs) with turnover up to ₹3 crore from F&Os trading, may apply for presumptive taxation. Profit is presumed to be 6% (for digital transactions) or 8% (for cash transactions) of turnover. It makes compliance easier, since detailed books of accounts or an audit are no longer necessary (except in cases when profit declarations are lower than the presumptive rate yet total income exceeds the basic exemption limit).

3. Hedging Transactions: Section 43(5)(a), (b), (c): Some contracts entered into only for purposes of hedging against losses that may arise due to price fluctuations on raw materials, merchandise, or shares do not fall under the ambit of speculative classification. This includes hedging by producers, merchants, or dealers to protect their core business.
4. Charitable Trusts and Exempt Institutions: Section 11: In general, someone would expect that income from speculation would be taxable in a charitable trust. However, suppose the trust is fully exempt under Section 11, and the speculative income is genuinely used for the trust’s charitable objects. In that case, it might therefore not need to be assessed separately for tax purposes. However, this would come with very stringent conditions concerning the pattern of investments mandated by Section 11(5), which largely restrains trusts from investing in speculative assets.

What is Not Exempt (and Specific Taxation)

1. Intraday Equity Trading Profits:
   • Always Speculative: These profits have always been classified as speculative business income.
   • Taxation: Taxation adds to the individual’s total income under “Profits and Gains from Business or Profession” and is taxed according to the individual’s marginal income tax rate as per applicable slab rates; tax rates of lower preference do not apply, nor benefits from indexation.
   • Loss Set-Off: Losses from intraday trades can only be set off against other speculative business income in the same financial year.
   • Loss Carry Forward:  Speculative losses may only be carried forward for a maximum of four assessment years; they can use qualified speculative business income in the future to offset losses.
   • Tax Audit: If, during any financial year, an intraday trader incurs a loss or declares a profit lower than 6% of turnover, and total income exceeds the basic exemption limit, then tax audit under Section 44AB is mandatory.
2. Unregistered or Unregulated Derivative Trading:
   • Profits from derivative trading not carried out on a recognized stock exchange are also treated as speculative business income. This is with respect to taxation and treatment of losses, similar to intraday equity.
3. Crypto or Virtual Digital Asset (VDA) Speculation (Section 115BBH):
   • Under section 115BBH, income from the transfer of VDAs (including cryptocurrencies) is taxed effective April 1, 2022 (AY 2023-24 onwards).
   • Flat Tax Rate: A flat tax rate of 30% applies to gains.
   • No Deductions/Expenses: No deductions, except for the acquisition cost or expenses, are allowed against VDA income.
   • No Loss Set-Off or Carry Forward: Losses from VDA transfers may not be set off against other kinds of income, nor can they be carried forward to the next year.
   • TDS: One percent TDS shall be levied on VDA transactions exceeding the specified thresholds under section 194S.
4. No Exemptions for Small Traders (Intraday Equity): This means that there is no exemption from the income threshold for small traders concerning intraday equity trading. Every single profit, even if minimal, from intraday trading is fully taxable under business income.

Get Started with TaxDunia 

In India, speculative income is generally taxed at higher rates, with limited benefits for loss adjustment. However, F&O trading on recognized exchanges has a more favorable tax treatment under specific provisions. The taxation of VDA is especially harsh. Adherence to reporting requirements coupled with wise professional tax advice is critical not only for maintaining compliance but also for financial optimization.